My brother, whom I now call Robert, grew up calling Robin, and is known to his friends as Bob is engaged in a short-short story class at a local college in the Walla Walla area where he lives. He sometimes shares his efforts with me and elicits my comments. This piece, which he gave me permission to print, was just too funny to be ignored. I publish it here for your edification and enjoyment. Following his submission, you will find my rebuttal. I think this is a perfect venue for comments. You will find the link at the bottom of the post. What's your take on the "perfect woman" or "perfect man?"
The Perfect Woman by Robert Griswold
Years ago some knucklehead gave me his interpretation of the perfect woman, as "a rich, beautiful, nymphomaniac, who owns a liquor store." That struck me as amusing, but did not fit my youthful vision of female perfection, which was: "a girl in possession of her own apartment, who was built like a brick shithouse, was eager to engage in frequent bouts of adult behavior, and was thoughtful enough to keep plenty of beer in her fridge."
Today, in my euphemistically designated Golden Years, that wish list requires geriatric modification. My current ideal of the perfect woman would be one who "lived in a comfortable house or apartment, free of children or annoying, smelly or hairy pets; be gracefully wrinkled, but not so much that I couldn't determine if she were smiling or frowning; would not be too disappointed if she encountered snores instead of fireworks when the lights were out; and when feeling amorous – and I was awake - would be satisfied with the occasional smooch as we watched a romantic movie; and finally, and perhaps most importantly, would own an espresso machine, with which she produced killer lattes on command.
To be painfully frank, over the half century plus I’ve sought involvement in romantic relationships, I have met women whom I considered perfect, or close enough to pass in a world where true perfection is impossible to find. But each of those women rejected me, because they were looking for the perfect man. Ironically, whenever a woman decided that I was perfect enough for her standards, I rejected her, usually because I believed I was too good to be involved with a woman who would stoop to having a guy like me as her main squeeze.
As you can see, dear reader - and probably knew before you picked up this bizarre essay - the whole romance business is terribly confusing. Several times since its publication in 1978, I’ve tried to crack the code of romantic entanglements by reading and rereading a hugely popular and well-received book focusing on relationships and love, “The Road Less Traveled,” by M Scott Peck, M.D., a clinical psychiatrist with many years of experience.
I homed in on “Section II: LOVE” because the enigma of love was the essence of my interest. In the first paragraph, however, I ran into a conundrum. On Page 81, Dr. Peck writes, “Love is too large, too deep ever to be truly understood or measured or limited within the framework of words.” Isn’t that great? If that’s true, why did he bother to write another 100 pages of words on that subject; and why should I trouble myself to read what he wrote? But I doggedly read on, only to discover that the good doctor believed “the experience of falling in love is invariably temporary. No matter whom we fall in love with, we sooner or later fall out of love.” What a bummer! Reading further, I discover that the “myth of romantic love is a dreadful lie,” and specifically that the crush, that intoxicating feeling individuals get when they’re convinced they’re “in love,” is dangerous, since it overwhelms the rational side of our nature and frequently causes people to do things they later regret, such as get married. This contention caused me to recall the lyrics of “Jackson,”a Johnny Cash song about “getting married in a fever, hotter than a pepper sprout. We’ve been talking about Jackson since the fire went out,” and also remembering the many people I’ve known, sadly including myself, who have done and said regrettable things under the influence of a crush.
Frustrated and depressed, I closed Dr. Peck’s book before I became an embittered cynic about my favorite subject. I once again pondered my expectations for my Perfect Woman. Was that a bogus dream, a muddle-headed fantasy, or something that simply needed to be reconsidered and reconfigured? If changes were necessary, what should I eliminate? Must the comfortable dwelling, free of annoying children or pets be sacrificed? The reasonably downgraded expectations in the area of physical intimacy? The humble espresso machine?
No, no, and hell no! I had all that stuff right in the first place. In addition, I said nothing about being taken in by the fickle myth of love, or the dangerous and transitory befuddlement of a crush. Therefore, I am free to continue with my search, satisfied that I am on the correct and proper course.
The End
My Reply:
The Perfect Man
Dear Brother,
I found your essay on "The Perfect Woman," to be right on. At least from one woman's perspective. Love, at least one's perception of it, is an eclectic collection of traits and niceties that one wishes the other person had or did. My "perfect man" would bring me coffee in the morning, without even asking. Indeed Jim does and that is the reason I married him. However, having married three other times in the heat of a crush has taught me that being able to check one thing off my "perfect man" list is not enough to make a happy lifetime together. Therefore, in order to assure this "perfect man" was going to make me happy after the crush passed, I increased my list and waited past the crush period before saying "I do." Or more accurately, announcing that I was now certain that he was the man I wanted to spend the rest of my life with. Which brings me back to my point: my list of necessaries for the "Perfect Man" contains not only a man who will bring me coffee in the morning, but someone who was good in bed the night before. Forgive me for being so blunt, but at my age one doesn't have time to beat around the bush. This "perfect man" also has to appreciate my wit and intellect; knowing that he is wrong most of the time, unless I tell him otherwise. And...he has to love my pets and not be overly overweight; but care not a wit that I am.
The End












